Year	Winner	Jockey, WT.	Owner	Trainer	second, Wt.	third, Wt.	Val. win	Time	Track
1875	Vinaigrette	J. Houston, 97	A. B. Lewis & Co.	N/A	Gyptis, 97	Elemi, 97	$1,175	2:39 3/4
1876	Necy Hale	W. James, 97	F. B. Harper	N/A	Plenty, 97	Lady Clipper, 97	1,900	2:42 1/2
1877	Felicia	W. James, 97	J. W. Reynolds	N/A	Bradamante, 97	Aunt Betsy, 97	2,550	2:39
1878	Belle of Nelson	Booth, 97	Mattingly & Co.	N/A	Buena Vista, 97	Fortuna, 97	2,650	2:39
1879	Liahtunah	Hightower, 97	J. A. Grinstead	N/A	Ada Glenn, 97	Buckden Lass, 97	3,350	2:40 1/4
1880	Longitude	J. McLaughlin, 102	J. G. Malone	N/A	Bye and Bye, 102	Ersilia, 102	3,250	2:41 3/4
1881	Lucy May	Wolfe, 102	R. F. Johnson	N/A	Belle of the Highlands, 102	Mrs. Chubbs, 102	3,000	2:41
1882	Katie Creel	J. Stoval, 102	Johnson & Co.	C. A. Johnson	Pinafore, 102	Issie, 102	3,240	2:39
1883	Vera	J. Stoval, 102	R. C. Pate	J. Pate	Orange Blossom, 102	Billetta, 102	3,220	2:39 3/4
1884	Modesty	I. Murphy, 105	Ed Corrigan	E. Corrigan	Highflight, 105	Bluette, 105	3,030	2:48 1/4
1885	Lizzie Dwyer	Fuller, 105	Ed Corrigan	E. Corrigan	Constellation, 105	Exile, 105	3,800	2:40 3/4
1886	Pure Rye	E. Garrison, 113	Melbourne Stable	N/A	Red Girl, 113	Ada D., 113	4,170	2:41
1887	Florimore	Johnston, 113	T. H. Stevens	D. W. Kelly	Wary, 113	Bannail, 113	3,330	2:40 3/4
1888	Ten Penny	A. McCarthy, Jr., 113	M. Welsh	N/A	Los Angeles, 114	Quindaro Bell, 113.5	3,770	2:42
1889	Jewel Ban	J. Stoval, 113	J. T. Clay	W. Clay	Bandolette, 113	Retrieve, 113	3,850	2:41
1890	English Lady	Hollis, 113	Scoggan Bros.	N/A	Marie K.*, 113		3,610	2:42 1/2
1891	Miss Hawkins	T. Britton, 117	Talbot Bros.	H. J. Talbot	Ethel, 117	Bonnie Bird, 117	3,860	2:18 1/4
1892	Miss Dixie	H. Ray, 117	Col. J. E. Pepper	M. Danaher	Unadilla, 117	Greenwich, 117	3,470	2:14 1/4
1893	Monrovia	J. Reagan, 117	Ed Brown	Ed Brown	Elizabeth L., 117	Joanna, 117	2,780	2:16
1894	Selika	A. Clayton, 117	Bashford Manor	J. H. Morris	Charity, 117	Shuttle, 117	2,600	2:15
1895	Voladora	A. Clayton, 117	Pastime Stable	N/A	Alabama, 117	Kathryn, 117	1,830	2:16 3/4
1896	Souffle	C. Thorpe, 112	J. M. Murphy	J. Healy	Myrtle Harkness, 112	La Gascoyne, 112	2,860	1:54 1/2
1897	White Frost	T. Burns, 112	E. S. Gardner & Son	L. C. Davis	Rosinante, 112	Taluca, 112	2,410	1:49
1898	Crocket	J. Hill, 112	J. C. Cahn	L. Cahn	Lennep, 112	Alleviate, 112	2,860	1:51 1/2
1899	Rush	J. Hill, 112	T. C. McDowell	T. C. McDowell	May Hempstead, 117	The Lady in Blue, 112	2,410	1:52 1/2
1900	Etta	M. Overton, 112	Ed Brown & Co.	Ed Brown	Scarlet Lily, 112	Cleora, 112	2,410	1:48

| 1875-1900 | 1901-1925 | 1926-1950 | 1951-1975 | 1976-2003 |